The Legacy, Part 2

A continuing story from The Legacy


On Wednesday April 24, 1929 Kay Yamamoto took the witness stand for one more round of questioning in a grueling trial that was more than a month old. The courtroom drama involved a legacy of property and trust but the politics and prejudices swirling around the case tested Tacoma’s most deep seated ideas about hard work, loyalty and shared history.

Kay’s attorney, Wesley Lloyd, began the questioning by walking the 41 year old father of five through his life story.  Then, on cross examination by opposing attorney Maurice Langhorne, Kay traced back over the same autobiography under a “thundering assault” on his loyalties, motives and race. 

Kichigoro (Kay) Yamamoto was Issei, born near Uwajima on Japan’s Shikoku island and as a boy of just 14 he followed his uncle, Yokichi Nakanishi, across the Pacific by steamship to Tacoma in 1902. Kay recounted for the court, working in the household of Mrs. C.M. Lawrence on South I Street where he learned English, and then joining his uncle’s growing truck farm operation near Fife.

The jury was charmed by Kay’s story cut.2of meeting his uncle’s landlord, a burley towering Irishman who bellowed with laughter watching the boy try unsuccessfully to milk his first cow. The man was John McAleer, and over the next decade “uncle Nakanishi” helped him turn a 40 acre dairy farm into a prosperous 300 acre vegetable growing enterprise called West Side Gardens. As McAleer bought and then leased more land for the gardens, and as the Japanese workers and their families grew in number, he helped arrange a language school for the community and then a gymnasium which Kay described in familiar terms. Kay didn’t mention that in 1912 he won the Pacific Northwest wrestling championship in the 125 lbs. weight class or that McAleer was delighted at the young man’s accomplishment.

Kay went on to remember that John McAleer and his wife Margaret built a stylish 10 room Arts & Crafts home near

John McAleer

the West Side Gardens in 1918, just as the war was ending. By then Kay was married to Masae and they had a growing family that would soon include two boys and three girls. The Japanese American community in Fife was counted at 1306 people in the 1920 Federal census and the workforce at West Side Gardens reached 40 not counting the truck drivers that carried more than $200,000 in produce each year to markets and restaurants across the Pacific Northwest.

But along with the growing field worker population and high quality vegetable production was an increasingly complicated

West Side Gardens Truck in Tacoma’s Nihonmachi ca. 1920. Densho Digital Archives, Magden Collection

political atmosphere. Issues of agricultural land use and property ownership became entangled in polarizing post-war politics at both the state and federal levels. Issei farmers like Kay and his uncle could not own land and even the terms of leases and sharecropping agreements were under increasing scrutiny by governments and political organizations. West Side Gardens was part of a patchwork of agricultural partnerships that were delicately created to contend with shifting land laws and permit Japanese, Italian and other immigrant farmers to work the fertile land in the Fife valley. The shift became an earthquake in 1920.


In his testimony on that Spring day in 1929 Kay passed lightly over how his uncle Nakanishi was summoned to the Federal Courthouse in Tacoma on July 28, 1920 to answer questions from the influential U.S. Congressional Committee on Immigration and Naturalization. The Committee was chaired by Congressman Albert Johnson, the country’s most powerful figure on immigration policy, who was at the time convening the hearings in his own district. Kay simply stated that after the Congressional hearing a decade earlier, his uncle’s West Side Garden’s went bankrupt due to changes in the laws.

Fife Language School. Densho Digital Archives, Magden Collection

In fact, the Tacoma and Seattle congressional hearings in 1920 were monumental in signaling a series of unprecedented laws and policies that changed the lives of farmers like Kay forever. The record is unclear about whether or not Kay was in the Federal Courthouse during his uncle’s appearance before the House Committee but the Tacoma Daily Ledger reported in detail on the testimony given that warm, windy summer day in 1920.   

July 28, 1920, Federal Courthouse, Tacoma……..

Chairman Albert Johnson opened the hearing by introducing the members present from the United States House of Representative Committee on Immigration and Naturalization including John Raker of California, William Viale of Colorado, Isaac Siegel of New York and John C. Box of Texas. Johnson was in very familiar surroundings having worked as a reporter and editor for the Tacoma News in publisher Sam Perkins’ building right across the street. After a stint at the Seattle Times and with Perkins financial help he became part owner and editor of the Daily Washingtonian in Hoquiam. In 1912 he ran successfully for congress from Washington’s 2nd District which in those day included Tacoma and Pierce County. And in 1919, after three terms as a minority member, he ascended to the chairmanship of the Committee on Immigration and Naturalization.

Rep. Johnson explained to the full courtroom that the Committee was investigating conditions on the west coast related to the “Japanese question”. From vitriolic statements made by members of the sub-committee, newspaper editorials and previous hearings in Washington D.C., it was expected that the Committee was preparing dramatic changes to Federal laws on limiting immigration, constricting pathways to naturalization and even limiting citizenship rights for native born Americans of Japanese descent. Information gathering sessions were held up and down the west coast that summer but most observers knew that the coming policies were a forgone conclusion and the hearings were little more that a campaign swing.

Under oath, the Committee heard testimony fromHouseCom hearings 1920.en M. Yoshida, Secretary of the Tacoma Japanese Association who presented a careful count of residents, businesses and industry in Tacoma and the Puyallup Valley. Kameji Nutahara, a pastor and S. Kuramoto a farmer and Miss Edith Moody, a health department statistician were questioned about birth certificates including several probing questions about whether the birth documents were provided to the Japanese government in order to receive dual citizenship for children. Ms. Moody and the others noted that the certificates were important to families because they documented citizenship for American born kids but the questions about disloyalty from the Congressmen made the unfounded suggestion part of the Congressional record.

Some of the most unexpected testimony of the day came from Willis R Lebo, a merchant in fish fertilizer and a keen observer of farming methods. Instead of just confirming the expanding acreage and production of Japanese operated vegetable and fruit farms in the Fife and Puyallup valley he went on to express his admiration for the hard work and methods he was seeing. It was not what the committee wanted to hear but on the front page of the Ledger it became a headline. Mr. Lebo then offered:

Mr. Nakanishi, of Fife is to my mind the dean of all agriculturalists. An intellectual in his own country, he is a scientific farmer who can grow three times as much as a white farmer on the same ground. He has taken a garden planted to cucumbers in rows five feet apart and planted lettuce between the rows, cleared $400 an acre from the lettuce and $600 an acre from the cucumbers.” ……”The first use of tractors in the valley was on Nakanishi’s 269 acres…..”

And then, Chairman Johnson interrupted, admonishing him to be careful in his statements. Unintentionally Lebo had put uncle Nakanishi in the crosshairs of the unhappy committee and his testimony was still to come. 

Congressman Vaile aimed a question at Lebo. “Do you think it desirable that an alien race should occupy the farmlands of the country?

“I think its unfortunate that we should get patriotism and love of country mixed with business” Lebo replied. He noted that just two years earlier, as the Army was ramping up for war the farmers in Thurston County fell behind in providing Camp Lewis with vegetables. The Army went to West Side Gardens for help and Nakanishi responded by providing $1000 a day in fresh produce, delivered to the cantonment.

Federal Building, Tacoma, WA

With the mood and tone heating up, chairman Johnson directed his own question at Lebo. “Which do you think is the greater man in the Puyallup Valley, Paulhamus or Nakanishi ?” It was a question that stunned the room for the unspoken implications it held.

Lebo answered, “Paulhamus holds a separate place. From the point of view of agriculture, Nakanishi is the greatest man on the Pacific Coast. I think the State could well afford to abandon its experimental station and hire one reporter to follow Nakanishi around his grounds to see how he eliminates plant pests, cultivates his soil and employs fertilizer and then writes it downInstead of coming to see the Mountain, I think people should come here to see West Side Gardens.”

Congressman Raker from California made it clear he was offended by the last remark and its possible reference to the motor trip the Committee had made the to Mountain the day before. In fact, virtually everything Lebo had said was contrary to the Committee’s attitude and perspective, particularly the comparison between the operator of West Side Gardens and the singular figure referred to as “Paulhamus”. With Yokichi Nakanishi waiting in the gallery Chairman Johnson called him to the testimony table.

William Hall Paulhamus, former State Senator, candidate for Governor and founder of the Puyallup Fair was now the invisible character in the room as the political drama unfolded. What was unsaid but widely known was that Johnson and Paulhamus were close allies in their anti-Japanese ideas and beliefs. Less known but barely concealed was that they both were closely aligned, if not full fledged members of the Ku Klux Klan.

It was under these circumstances that questioning began for Yokichi Nakanishi on the afternoon of July 28, 1920 in Tacoma, Washington.


The Legacy Part 3 is next…..



The Legacy, Part 1



U.S. House of Representatives, Japanese Immigration, Hearings before the Committee on Immigration and Naturalization, part 4, hearings at Seattle and Tacoma, July-August, 1920, (Washington, 1921), 1413-1425, 

Gordon, Linda, The Second Coming of the KKK: The Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s and the American Political Tradition. New York : Liveright Publishing Corporation, [2017] ©2017

Nelson, The Alien Land Law Movement of the Late Nineteenth Century, 54; Douglas Pullen, The Administration of Washington State Governor Louis F. Hart 1919-1925, PhD Dissertation, University of Washington, 1974, 226

Charles McClain, Japanese Immigrants and American Law: The Alien Land Laws and Other Issues (Garland Publishing Inc, New York, 1994), 30 


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: